Xtreme PB&J

Xtreme PB&J

NOT just for kids! Vanilla Cake filled with one layer of Peanut Butter Buttercream and one layer of Strawberry Jam. Covered with Cake Crumbs then topped with Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups, Reese’s Pieces, Peanut Butter Chips and Peanut M&M’s


In production all of our equipment and utensils are used to bake and create cakes that have nuts, gluten, dairy, eggs, wheat and other possible allergens.


Date Cake Is Needed? *

Cake Delivery Options *

Would you prefer to pickup or have it delivered?

Pick-up at the Bakeshop

Available Monday through Friday 10am to 3pm

Butterfly Bakeshop
133 East 39th Street (between Lex & 3rd)
2nd Floor, Suite #1

We do not have a retail store; we are located in a commercial brownstone.
Go through the metal gate, up the stairs and ring the Butterfly Doorbell on the left.


Full Delivery Address and Notes *

Name, Cross Streets, Apartment, Suite # etc.

Select Delivery Area *

Delivery Window *

Special Instructions

i.e., OK to leave with doorman, use service entrance etc.

Gold Celebration Topper*

Top your Cake with a Gold Celebration Message!


There are no reviews yet.

Be the first to review “Xtreme PB&J”