Rachel
Rachel
NYC
Gorgeous, delicious and reasonably priced birthday cake

We used Butterfly Bakeshop to make my birthday cake for my 40th birthday party. I had a design in my mind and they executed it perfectly - it was exactly how I envisioned it! The cake was chocolate with salted caramel filling and it was absolutely delicious - moist and not too rich or sweet. I looked at other bakeries but chose Butterfly because other reviewers said the cakes are as delicious as they are beautiful and that is not always the case with other bakeries in NYC. They were a pleasure to deal with from start to finish and they even delivered to the restaurant. I found the price to be extremely reasonable. Butterfly exceeded my expectations in every way!

Avatar
Julie
NYC
Awesome Superman Cake!

We ordered a Superman Cake for our son's 4th birthday and not only was it a work of art, but it was also delicious! We received numerous compliments from friends on how good the cake tasted in addition to it being great looking. Most importantly, our little guy LOVED it - especially the edible "4" and "superman" cake topper!

Avatar
Allison
NYC
AMAZING

Butterfly was able to make our Wheel of Fortune viewing party for a coworker absolutely spectacular with a cake made to resemble the wheel...not to mention DELICIOUS!

Avatar
Stephanie
NYC
Awesome Cake!

We ordered the Superhero cake and it was perfection :)! The kids loved it, and it was absolutely delicious. I would definitely order from Butterfly Bakeshop again. They also delivered the cake to the party location, which was great!

Sarah Fitzgerald
Sarah Fitzgerald
NYC
Super tasty birthday cake

I ordered a New York Rangers cake for my brother's 30th birthday. The cake looked wonderful, but the biggest surprise was how delicious it was! One of the best custom cakes I've had. Filling was moist, icing the perfect consistency. I wish I knew about Butterfly for my wedding cake.

Ben Ladisa
Ben Ladisa
Mill Neck
Custom Name Cake

This is the third time we've used Butterfly Bakeshop for our custom name cake. Once again they've outdone themselves with their beautiful artistry and outstanding flavor!!!

Jillian
Jillian
NYC
Spectacular Thanksgiving Cake

Butterfly created a truly beautiful cake--and it was absolutely delicious too. Butterfly's bakers are truly gifted food artisans! The cake anchored our holiday buffet and our guests could hardly wait for us to cut it!

Anna
Anna
NYC
Crowd Pleaser!

Not only was this cake so fun to look at it was delicious! My husband being a huge golf fan - and this was a surprise - made this cake the perfect choice. The process was also seamless when working with Butterfly Bakeshop - Can't wait to plan my 3 year old's cake soon!

Mary Ann
Mary Ann
New York City
Exquisite Cake and Cupcakes!!!

The cake and cupcakes for my daughter's movie themed RIO 2 party were a HUGE success! Guests were amazed at how beautiful and delicious the cake and accompanying cupcakes were. The chocolate cake was moist and the frosting perfect! We will definitely be back again next year for the third year in a row. Thank you to everyone at Butterfly Bakeshop...and special thanks to Orlando the cake artist--phenomenal job!!!!

Heather McCoy
Heather McCoy
Upstream Group, Burlington Vermont
Corporate Celebration

I hired Butterly from our HQ in Burlington, Vermont for a celebration we were going to be having in NY. They were easy to work with and did everything through email which took a lot of pressure off me. And to top that off, the cake was delicious and a huge hit!


Please Leave Your Own Testimonial!

Have you purchased a cake from Butterfly Bakeshop? Let Us (and Everyone) know how it was. Please take a moment to fill out the following testimonial about your experince.

Thank you!

Butterfly Bakeshop

84 + 3 =
Read all of our Wedding Cake Reviews at Weddings, Wedding Cakes,  Wedding Planning, Wedding Checklists, Free Wedding Websites, Wedding Dresses, Wedding Ideas & more