Melissa
Melissa
New York, NY
Beautiful Baptism Cake

The cake was beautiful and tasted amazing. The staff was easy to work with and was able to accommodate our last minute cake order! It was exactly what i was looking for.

Avatar
Phyllis
New York
Hit of the party

Butterfly's outstanding and creative cake for our family birthday party made it a very special occasion. The looks on my brother and sister in law's faces when they saw the clever cut-outs of their favorite hobbies - priceless! And the taste was as delicious as the presentation.
Thank you for a sweet ending to a lovely evening.

Dorothy
Dorothy
NYC
Artful and Tasty!

I was so happy to have this cake at my birthday party, before I even saw it the staff were telling me how beautiful it was and when it finally came out, I took hundreds of photos. When my friends came in, that was the only thing they saw for the first half of the party. In addition to being beautiful, the cake tasted amazing (it was lemon cake with strawberry icing), exactly the summer feeling I wanted and I was so happy there was extra- we ate it for weeks later. Thank you so much butterfly bake shop for making my beautiful cake, with such great service- they e-mailed me back and forth to make sure the cake was exactly what I wanted.

Avatar
Nyisha
Tampa, FL
Simple yet elegant wedding cake

The cake for our wedding was delicious! The buttercream was so smooth it looked like fondant. We had red velvet, chocolate, and vanilla cake with buttercream frosting and everyone loved it. Butterfly Bakeshop is very accommodating and made purchasing the cake for my wedding in NYC, all the way from Florida, easy and hassle free! I will definitely recommend them to others. Great cake, great value, great experience!!

Tanya
Tanya
Texas
Custom wedding cake

Loved the attention to detail in creating our custom wedding cake! Exceeded our expectations!

Jessica Taylor
Jessica Taylor
New York, NY
The Perfect Groom's Cake

I knew exactly what I wanted for a Groom's cake for my husband, and Butterfly Bake Shop made it come to life! Not only were they very responsive to all my inquiries, but also very detailed in explaining all the options I could choice from. When guests walked into our rehearsal dinner and saw the cake displayed, everyone was shocked at how perfect it was and excited to eat it as well!! Thank you for helping to make such a special time even more memorable!

Constantina Louk
Constantina Louk
Queens, NY
Guava & Dulce de Leche - My new Favorite Flavor!

I loved my butterfly experience! Definitely a cake to remember. I was inspired by a cake from the gallery that I needed a few tweeks on... AND VOILA! My best friends 30th birthday cake was created. Best customer service I have ever experience with a company, please try them out for your special occasion. Also, do try the Guava and Dulce de leche filling - to die for!

Avatar
Kimberly Richardson
Freehold, NJ
Amazing wedding cake!

Butterfly Bakeshop was such a find; it was very overwhelming finding a bakery in NYC that would do a relatively small wedding cake (35 guests) for a reasonable price. Many places flat out told me that it was not worth the effort to make a cake so small. Butterfly though was as accommodating as could be -- especially helpful since I don't live in NYC but was getting married there. Our tasting was incredible (and free! a rarity); their unique flavor combinations cannot be found anywhere else. We wound up going with a simple Swiss dot with twisted rope design, and the cake was so pretty! We had a lemon cake with honey-ginger buttercream filling -- perfect for summer. Everyone was RAVING about how delicious the cake was. And lastly, Butterfly was significantly cheaper than any other bakery - in fact, the final product, including delivery, was close to $200 cheaper than any other bakery I could find. An absolute gem of a business!

C Reyes
C Reyes
Manhattan
Stunning and Delicious

I had only two days to make some magic happen when my job gave me the daunting task of getting a wedding cake to celebrate an employee getting married in Jamaica. Stacey was so friendly and accommodating with my budget. I was very apprehensive about the tasting quality of the cake since we had never ordered before with Butterfly Bakeshop. The results were truly incredible. The cake resembled a Jamaican flag with the colors and the taste was far better than any other wedding cake I've ever had. Everyone in the office really liked it and inquired where I purchased the cake. Hopefully we can use them again. Great customer service and good quality is hard to come by these days and Butterfly Bakeshop is on the top of my list.
Thanks.

Bessie Leveson-Morris
Bessie Leveson-Morris
Brooklyn NYC
Amazing! Exceeded expectations!

Wow is all I can say! The cake was not only perfect to look at but tasted amazing! I had people telling me normally they don't enjoy wedding cake and that ours was delicious!! It was also stunning and far exceeded any expectations I had for what a wedding cake could look like 🙂 It matched our wedding and our colors perfectly, it was beautiful and took my breath away! The baker and staff were all friendly and helpful!! 100% highly recommend Butterfly Bakeshop and hope to use again!


Please Leave Your Own Testimonial!

Have you purchased a cake from Butterfly Bakeshop? Let Us (and Everyone) know how it was. Please take a moment to fill out the following testimonial about your experince.

Thank you!

Butterfly Bakeshop

76 + 4 =

Read all of our Wedding Cake Reviews at Weddings, Wedding Cakes,  Wedding Planning, Wedding Checklists, Free Wedding Websites, Wedding Dresses, Wedding Ideas & more